A rather different type of extortion, originally published on Chainmailcheck, but reproduced here with some additional commentary.
Here’s an interesting article by Brian Krebs: Sextortion Scam Uses Recipient’s Hacked Passwords
The scammer claims to have made a video of the intended victim watching porn, and threatens to send it to their friends unless payment is made. Not particularly novel: the twist with this one is that it “references a real password previously tied to the recipient’s email address.” Krebs suggests that the scammer is using a script to extract passwords and usernames from a known data breach from at least ten years ago.
The giveaway is that very few people are likely to be using the same password now – and it’s unlikely that there are that many people receiving the email who might think that such a video could have been made. Still, it seems that some people have actually paid up, and it’s possible that a more convincing attack might be made sending a more recent password to a given email address, and perhaps using a different type of leverage.
[Commentary from Sophos here.]
Additional commentary from me since the Chainmailcheck article:
In a related *thread on Reddit, one comment indicated that there have also been attempts to log on to accounts associated with the same user using the leaked password, which I’d say amounts to a good reason for:
(a) Not using the same password across multiple accounts in general (though some people use a ‘throwaway’ password on ‘throwaway’ accounts where a later breach wouldn’t actually matter).
(b) Checking other accounts where you might have duplicated a password. It’s perfectly possible in such a case that the password is no longer current on the email account where the extortion mail was received, but not on other accounts, perhaps used less often.
One slightly disturbing feature of that Reddit thread is that it was sparked by an extortionate email to an admin account where the password given by the scammer was still current. Fortunately, the company concerned seems to have taken appropriate actions on seeing the email, but it’s a salutary reminder that administrators are not always any better at routine security measures than the rest of us.
*Hat tip to ESET’s Aryeh Goretsky for bringing it to my attention.